• There is NO official Otland's Discord server and NO official Otland's server list. The Otland's Staff does not manage any Discord server or server list. Moderators or administrator of any Discord server or server lists have NO connection to the Otland's Staff. Do not get scammed!

OTClient There is no main OTClient repo?

hiwyn

Member
Joined
Aug 30, 2021
Messages
35
Reaction score
5
Why there is 3 otclients here on forum?

1

2

3 (looks the best for now)
GitHub - mehah/otclient: An alternative tibia client for otserv written in C++11 and Lua, made with a modular system that uses lua scripts for ingame interface and functionality, making otclient flexible and easy to customize (https://github.com/mehah/otclient)

???

I'm a linux player and I don't even know which should i use...
Why everybody don't work in only one, so it be always the best?

(searching about otc i see a lot of topics of otv8, there is a lot of new accounts promoting it, pls don't comment here, its close source project by one man, i don't want to use this close project)
 

Kaspar

Unprejudiced
Staff member
Global Moderator
Joined
Jun 2, 2016
Messages
771
Solutions
2
Reaction score
817
Location
Stockholm
I would like to remind users to respect the original poster's request of not discussing a certain topic in his/her thread.
Otherwise we will deem those posts as off-topic. If you would like to discuss the ongoing side-topic further then please create your own thread about it.

Thank you in advance.
 
OP
OP
hiwyn

hiwyn

Member
Joined
Aug 30, 2021
Messages
35
Reaction score
5
I would like to remind users to respect the original poster's request of not discussing a certain topic in his/her thread.
Otherwise we will deem those posts as off-topic. If you would like to discuss the ongoing side-topic further then please create your own thread about it.

Thank you in advance.

omg ty

i was talking about the community projects, kondra's isn't one...
okay he got money in a project he did not create?
i don't admire it but the license allow him to do it

i'm trying to support the people who made it possible, that's why i'll never use a closed server also never use a closed client
i've ask to don't bring this on the first topic on the thread, every topic about otc some fakes/bootlicker bring this otcv8

i wanna use the community official so if i find something i can help, everybody gain the benefits, with no original sources it can become hard...
 
OP
OP
hiwyn

hiwyn

Member
Joined
Aug 30, 2021
Messages
35
Reaction score
5
No one said it doesn't work.

Privatizing an open source project and charging people to use it... Just a shady practice.

I get that people take some open source project and work on it themselves, that's fine, but to turn around and openly be selling your flavor of it is just dodgy. I'm not even sure how it's legal.

It's like taking a linux distro, adding a couple features and trying to sell it. But they, there's people willing to do this and you found a way to make money. Money isn't everything.

this is negligible, but it is in accordance with the license placed in otclient
but my whole point is i don't want to flame anyone here, so the topic is not about that and i don't want to talk about that

i read this forum for a long time and i get lost with this 3 reps, imagine someone newest then me
for what i could see for now, i hope the meha's changes comes to the main repo and the otland repo get deleted
so we have the original otclient burning again
 

Nekiro

Legendary OT User
TFS Developer
Joined
Sep 7, 2015
Messages
2,497
Solutions
113
Reaction score
1,748
this is negligible, but it is in accordance with the license placed in otclient
but my whole point is i don't want to flame anyone here, so the topic is not about that and i don't want to talk about that

i read this forum for a long time and i get lost with this 3 reps, imagine someone newest then me
for what i could see for now, i hope the meha's changes comes to the main repo and the otland repo get deleted
so we have the original otclient burning again
I hope not. Mehah client is like 60% rewritten, imagine pushing that to the old stagnant repository which has no real maintainers.
 

Terotrificy

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 18, 2020
Messages
239
Solutions
9
Reaction score
75
Location
Santiago, Chile.
this is negligible, but it is in accordance with the license placed in otclient
but my whole point is i don't want to flame anyone here, so the topic is not about that and i don't want to talk about that

i read this forum for a long time and i get lost with this 3 reps, imagine someone newest then me
for what i could see for now, i hope the meha's changes comes to the main repo and the otland repo get deleted
so we have the original otclient burning again
Edubart's client is the real one, Mehah is the customized version, in a way to fix bugs and enhance it. Then you have Otcv8 that is probably way better, but not an open-source.

Since the genius Edubart is not anymore in this community, all i can recommend you is to start your own branch from Edubart or stick and help to improve Mehah otclient. You can also look at the way Otcv8 works (it handles most of the features through lua i.e) and merge them to any of the repos.

Anyway, the most skilled guys are busy working irl because time is money. If we really want to have a quality client with great features, we should stop of relying on Mehah for free and letting Kondra do his business and instead should pay a small amount of $ to a team of skilled guys monthly to openly develop it. Mehah will not last forever.
 

zbizu

Legendary OT User
Joined
Nov 22, 2010
Messages
3,148
Solutions
20
Reaction score
2,306
Location
Poland
GitHub
Zbizu
we should stop of relying on Mehah for free and letting Kondra do his business and instead should pay a small amount of $ to a team of skilled guys monthly to openly develop it. Mehah will not last forever.
Nothing really stops you from donating to Mehah to support his project.
 

Terotrificy

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 18, 2020
Messages
239
Solutions
9
Reaction score
75
Location
Santiago, Chile.
Nothing really stops you from donating to Mehah to support his project.
I don't use Mehah's client, i do have my own branch of Edubart's client, but if at any point i merge some code from Mehah's to Edubart's, i would donate to him.
Anyway, when you donate to someone, he is free to advance at the speed / topics he wants to, in the other hand, when you pay someone, he have to meet deadlines for certain topics.
 
OP
OP
hiwyn

hiwyn

Member
Joined
Aug 30, 2021
Messages
35
Reaction score
5
I hope not. Mehah client is like 60% rewritten, imagine pushing that to the old stagnant repository which has no real maintainers.
Why not?

Why not merge the old one with the meha's one, those changes are not improvements?
And about maintainers i was talking about meha's becomes a maintainer on the orignal rep (with everybody else he want)

What @edubart (is this his user?) and @Mehah thinks about this?
 
Top