.~~~::|-[Voting thread]-|::~~~.
Of Mapping competition #17 (Underwater)
______________________________________________________
Welcome again.
Now the time is over... The created pictures will be shown below here, but first let me refresh your memory a little.
Deep.. under the sea lives many water creatures. Old ancient temples surrounded with plants and rocks are builded by the most feared monsters of the sea, with overwhelming magical and physic power it results in a domination of the sea. It's up to you to make a such place. If you're creative enough and keep to the things I've said it won't be a problem for you.
In this contest they could make at least 3 pictures of a place at their choice and if you want to know more about the contest (regarding the rules) then visit the sign-up thread which can be found here!
Rules for voting!
- Don't vote on yourself!
- Don't make multiple accounts to vote on yourself
- Don't advertise or a campaign to make people to vote on you!
Please keep in mind that I'm reviewing all the pictures that has been send to me and the ratings are based on the facts I see in my eyes! So you may not agree what I say.
Mc-Pedro:
Theme
5/10
It might be a place surrounded by rocks but it's not a kind type place for a temple and I won't call that a dangerous place that is feared by people so your score on this is pretty low.
Originality
5/10
It isn't much special nor really new or something.
Creativity
5.8/10
Well the first thing I saw when I reviewing your map is the sea water you made underwater it's impossible to be there, then I went looking at the order you used the stones it isn't good either, it's a bit spam of stones. So use less of those stone rubble and put some water plants to.
Playability
10/10
There's nothing wrong, nothing blocking the way by mistakes.
Total score: 25.8 points
Sharp:
Theme
8/10
You have have followed the theme right and so the score gets better though I don't see really a temple.
Originality
7/10
Not a really place that I would say "unique" but yet I haven't seen this kind of mapping much before.
Creativity
6.7/10
I don't get why you have made a waterfall in a underwater place, though your second picture is much better but there are missing mountain borders which makes it less attractive.
Playability
10/10
There's nothing wrong, nothing blocking the way by mistakes.
Total score: 31.7 points
Ryuuke:
Theme
9/10
You have followed the small story and made a cool dangerous place of it where evil monsters could be. Your score on this one is the best in my opinion
Originality
8/10
Also on this one you score pretty high. You have used the new 8.40 walls which is allowed it's makes it more better looking.
Creativity
8/10
You have used the new items wisely and therefore you have a 8 for it.
Not much to say about it except that it's good.
Playability
8/10
You can get there as the stone of the entrance at the north is blocking it and it's also quite narrow for playing.
Total score: 33
##############
I've decided to give the 7 votes to Ryuuke as he has earned the most points.
Now you can vote on the best picture you think that is a vote worth:
1- Mc-Pedro
2- Sharp
3- Ryuuke
Happy voting!
Of Mapping competition #17 (Underwater)
______________________________________________________
Welcome again.
Now the time is over... The created pictures will be shown below here, but first let me refresh your memory a little.
Deep.. under the sea lives many water creatures. Old ancient temples surrounded with plants and rocks are builded by the most feared monsters of the sea, with overwhelming magical and physic power it results in a domination of the sea. It's up to you to make a such place. If you're creative enough and keep to the things I've said it won't be a problem for you.
In this contest they could make at least 3 pictures of a place at their choice and if you want to know more about the contest (regarding the rules) then visit the sign-up thread which can be found here!
Rules for voting!
- Don't vote on yourself!
- Don't make multiple accounts to vote on yourself
- Don't advertise or a campaign to make people to vote on you!
Please keep in mind that I'm reviewing all the pictures that has been send to me and the ratings are based on the facts I see in my eyes! So you may not agree what I say.
Mc-Pedro:
Theme
5/10
It might be a place surrounded by rocks but it's not a kind type place for a temple and I won't call that a dangerous place that is feared by people so your score on this is pretty low.
Originality
5/10
It isn't much special nor really new or something.
Creativity
5.8/10
Well the first thing I saw when I reviewing your map is the sea water you made underwater it's impossible to be there, then I went looking at the order you used the stones it isn't good either, it's a bit spam of stones. So use less of those stone rubble and put some water plants to.
Playability
10/10
There's nothing wrong, nothing blocking the way by mistakes.
Total score: 25.8 points
Sharp:
Theme
8/10
You have have followed the theme right and so the score gets better though I don't see really a temple.
Originality
7/10
Not a really place that I would say "unique" but yet I haven't seen this kind of mapping much before.
Creativity
6.7/10
I don't get why you have made a waterfall in a underwater place, though your second picture is much better but there are missing mountain borders which makes it less attractive.
Playability
10/10
There's nothing wrong, nothing blocking the way by mistakes.
Total score: 31.7 points
Ryuuke:
Theme
9/10
You have followed the small story and made a cool dangerous place of it where evil monsters could be. Your score on this one is the best in my opinion
Originality
8/10
Also on this one you score pretty high. You have used the new 8.40 walls which is allowed it's makes it more better looking.
Creativity
8/10
You have used the new items wisely and therefore you have a 8 for it.
Not much to say about it except that it's good.
Playability
8/10
You can get there as the stone of the entrance at the north is blocking it and it's also quite narrow for playing.
Total score: 33
##############
I've decided to give the 7 votes to Ryuuke as he has earned the most points.
Now you can vote on the best picture you think that is a vote worth:
1- Mc-Pedro
2- Sharp
3- Ryuuke
Happy voting!
Last edited:
