which one looks the closest?

[IMac]

or

here the image of what im trying to make 3D into 2D btw

ignore the added items such as status/flags

 

[Leftwing]

They both look like shit, but the second is definitely better.

 

[Abeto]

2nd

 

[Fippex]

If i had to choise the first

 

[Tenhum]

umm
second

 

[jogui1]

3rd XD

 

[Sizaro]

Lol, you suck at Conquer.. ^.-

 

[The Mapper]

Both suck, but I much prefer the second.

 

[Henkos]

sry big fail XD

 

[Amrosh]

hmm i think i would choose the second one.

 

[Myths]

They both look bad, and the half roofs you have sticking off the side make it look worse.

This is personally how I do roofs. If it helps, and you would like to use it, please rep++