OK so here comes my ratinggazm.
i will use my system to Rate, and i will set them in the order of the scores my vote goes to highest score.
i will also be very harsh here, since it's a contest.
________________________________________________________________
1st: Xadrian
Rates:
-5/10(Bad)
5-7/10(Average)
8-9.9/10(Good)
Variation: 9/10
Detail: 10/10
Environment: 8.5/10
Nature: 9/10
Bonus:
Creative: Yes (yes:+1/10)(no:+0/10)
Overall score: 37.5/40
comment: Again a Nice piece of mapping. i gave Envi an 8.5 because i think the Building's are a bit to crowded. anyways nice mapping really. :thumbup:
________________________________________________________________
2nd: Zisly
Rates:
-5/10(Bad)
5-7/10(Average)
8-9.9/10(Good)
Variation: 8.5/10
Detail: 9.5/10
Environment: 9/10
Nature: 9/10
Bonus:
Creative: No (yes:+1/10)(no:+0/10)
Overall score: 36/40
comment: Nice piece of mapping like above. However not very creative :/ since a house in the middle of a forest against a mountain is mapped very often so no bonus for you. sorry. but still very nice nature good detail in the house, nice mountain and that really makes it up. :thumbup:
________________________________________________________________
3th: Kelmo
Rates:
-5/10(Bad)
5-7/10(Average)
8-9.9/10(Good)
Variation: 9/10
Detail: 9/10
Environment: 8/10
Nature: 8.5/10
Bonus:
Creative: Yes (yes:+1/10)(no:+0/10)
Overall score: 35.5/40
comment: Some nice peice of mapping there yes. veary unique and original. doh, on the last Pic there could be a bit more nature on the cliffs itself. :thumbup:
________________________________________________________________
4th: Rockydog
Rates:
-5/10(Bad)
5-7/10(Average)
8-9.9/10(Good)
Variation: 7.5/10
Detail: 8/10
Environment: 8/10
Nature: 7/10
Bonus:
Creative: Yes (yes:+1/10)(no:+0/10)
Overall score: 31.5/40
comment: Hmm some of the lesser mapping on the contest but still very Good. Maybe under detailed, and the Ground is a bit to boring 2 but still thats Mather of opinion. it's a nice swamp. keep working keep mapping and you will get better and better.:thumbup:
________________________________________________________________
Good Job to all contestants an my vote goes to Xadrian.
My the mapping be with you.
Kind Regards,
Yours Phoonix.