[Official OtLand Mapping Contest] June - Edron Magic Academy Revamp

Which piece(s) are you voting for?


  • Total voters
    71
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
OP
Scarlet Ayleid

Scarlet Ayleid

Intermediate OT User
Joined
Jul 7, 2007
Messages
4,056
Best answers
0
Reaction score
234
I voted on the third piece by mistake, I was going to vote for the second piece.

But whatever, it looks like the second piece will win without my vote anyway.
I'll update it

- - - Updated - - -

I want to change my vote to 3 :(.
It's simple, clean, RPG-ish and magicfull.
I love that.

I found 2 and 4 a bit to spammed, 1 looks unfinished.
All looks nice.
I'll update it
 

GhostX

Mapping Board Moderator
Staff member
Board Moderator
Joined
Nov 2, 2011
Messages
5,742
Best answers
0
Reaction score
984
Location
England; land of the slaves.
I voted for 3 because i feel it captured the theme subtlety and has a nice atmosphere. But dat ambient on 2 is awsome. I feel 2 is an awesome peice but NOT a student friendly magic academy.. More like a derelict corrupted ex academy xD

1- wrong environment imo.. Needed another pic probably in game since the other two have..
4- meh, it's okay, overview does it more justice but probably needed an in game pic to compete with the rest.

The in game overview on 2 is pretty coo

But overall the atmosphere of #3 is my favourite.
 

ZezeI

Intermediate OT User
Joined
Mar 2, 2011
Messages
247
Best answers
0
Reaction score
19
Location
Argentina
I will go for number 2, its perefect detailed! The only thing i dislike is the ground usen on bridges
 

Darklord

aneroth
Joined
Dec 17, 2008
Messages
1,001
Best answers
0
Reaction score
875
Location
athumanityhasdeclinedworld
with this poll now I have a clear idea of what people see for revamp an area

piece number 1, doesn't really change the towers or add something new to they, I only see a change of walls and for me those walls sucks
piece number 2, there we see a in some ways well done map piece... is ok and maybe looks nice but looks so freaking away of how the towers really was
piece number 3, is ok, doesn't show a good image of the whole towers but after all gives and idea of how the towers are and looks
piece number 4, looks a little bit like a "noob" piece, I see less water and more earth, don't like

all this comments are from my point of view & I tried to be indifferent

adding a final comment. in recent competitions do not see too much effort into the contestants
 
Last edited by a moderator:

poopsiedoodle

Gibe moni plos
Joined
Nov 23, 2011
Messages
2,432
Best answers
0
Reaction score
514
Location
Florida
Fuck, seriously? I'm the only one that voted for #1? Fuck you guys too -.-

hue
 

Znooc

Banned User
Joined
Dec 16, 2012
Messages
178
Best answers
0
Reaction score
14
I can vote for 1 with you ^^ 2 votes now \o/
 

Magnetico

Veteran OT User
Joined
Jan 18, 2010
Messages
3,635
Best answers
0
Reaction score
344
Location
mx
Holy guacamole! Everyone did an excelent job, seriously, but it goes without saying, #2 is the best by far IMO.
 

macedoon

ups & downs
Premium User
Joined
Dec 29, 2007
Messages
2,267
Best answers
0
Reaction score
538
Location
Netherlands
Number 2 was not a revamp, in my honest opinion. She/He changed everything that about it. It doesn't look like an academic neither does it have the same buildings. If the buildings were correct then I would've voted for 2 but I don't see a revamp in this.
 

Peroxide

Gone since January 2018
Joined
Aug 22, 2008
Messages
10,353
Best answers
0
Reaction score
1,919
Location
New Zealand
Number 2 was not a revamp, in my honest opinion. She/He changed everything that about it. It doesn't look like an academic neither does it have the same buildings. If the buildings were correct then I would've voted for 2 but I don't see a revamp in this.
re·vamp
/rēˈvamp/

Verb
Give new and improved form, structure, or appearance to: "revamp her image".
Noun
An act of improving the form, structure, or appearance of something.
Synonyms
renovate - mend - remodel
 

Znooc

Banned User
Joined
Dec 16, 2012
Messages
178
Best answers
0
Reaction score
14
Revamp = Destroy the original
 

macedoon

ups & downs
Premium User
Joined
Dec 29, 2007
Messages
2,267
Best answers
0
Reaction score
538
Location
Netherlands
I'll be damned, I didn't see that one, apologies :) Would have been more awesome if the other buildings were like in ruin! I know that it doesn't really matter anymore but 2 should have my vote.. it felt like cheat earlier :p
 
OP
Scarlet Ayleid

Scarlet Ayleid

Intermediate OT User
Joined
Jul 7, 2007
Messages
4,056
Best answers
0
Reaction score
234
I still don't like 2!!!

Its well mapped, but goes against the idea of the Magic Academy, its a school, not a dungeon! lol
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top