Well I'm talking about statistics not only personal preference. It's beyond what you and me think as the servers are dying out slowly but surely. And it's definitely not due to lack of content, is it?
We didn't start to play Tibia/Medivia because we wanted flashy graphics that's for sure. And it's not about the graphics per se, I mean Saphron is a great artist. But it's about the feeling when you login of what you are playing. Tibia or Zezenia (for example) or any other game. It affect the players more than you think even though it's nice graphics