[Remere's Map Editor: Redux] - Introducing RME overhaul project, because someone had to do it.

[Olddies]

probably some AI have "stole" your job
dont be mad man

Actually this ai thing did save me alot of money and also of my own time, right now i dont have to wait or pay someone else if i can pay just 20$ monthly and have the job done, im sure he is crying because of that

 

[Webtimize]

Actually this ai thing did save me alot of money and also of my own time, right now i dont have to wait or pay someone else if i can pay just 20$ monthly and have the job done, im sure he is crying because of that

You just put in wording the difference between leveraging AI and people not knowing how to code i guess. I'm not crying that 99% of OTLand can't write a single line of code. I'm not crying at all. it's somewhere very understandable that thing are being vibecoded. I'm laughing fucking loudly XDDDD

Good for you you save some time!

Edit; There are likely more bugs I haven't caught yet" That's fucking funny to me and tells me the state of the "vibey" project.

 

[poe6man3]

You just put in wording the difference between leveraging AI and people not knowing how to code i guess. I'm not crying that 99% of OTLand can't write a single line of code. I'm not crying at all. it's somewhere very understandable that thing are being vibecoded. I'm laughing fucking loudly XDDDD

Good for you you save some time!

Edit; There are likely more bugs I haven't caught yet" That's fucking funny to me and tells me the state of the "vibey" project.

I did now know that every project that was released before ai was a thing was bug free damn i must be born yesterday

 

[oen432]

The issue with vibe coded software is not that it wasn't coded by hand but that the author in 99% of the cases has no freaking idea what AI just did and why it works (if it works). So whenever new issue occurs, they have to depend on the AI to do the job, they can't help but prompt "fix this". At some point the issue will be so complicated that the AI won't be able to handle it and then what? Author won't fix it cause they don't have the knowledge to do so and any other dev won't touch this mess of a code.

Honestly, be grateful that it works, pray that it will continue working.

 

[jeanphilip]

Vibe coded? Disgusting attribution to the community. Not sure if RME is dead but he would certainly turn around in his grave.

who cares, it does the work . so what the problem¡

 

[sebastian97]

Hm, this looks quite promising. The dark theme looks really nice, and the LOD idea was much needed for the editor. I am seeing a bit of regression (which I know, you admitted that in the original post, but please, allow me to nitpick a little).

I feel like leaving a bunch of different LLM related files (Gemini, Claude, Qwen) does feel a bit like its polluting the codebase. I certainly don't have an issue with using LLMs to assist with programming (I do the same), but when searching around the codebase from the root directory, it does create a bit of noise. I feel like these files are more personal to the user developing and shouldn't be a part of the codebase. And I'm noticing on things like PR's like 3 different coding agent bots jump in. Seems a little excessive, no? Maybe just one good one?

I also think you should really try not to break critical things, like right now the scripting is completely broken. It might be better in the future to just keep all functionality, and only push commits that either do a complete refactor, or don't break things (which I get, maybe with the monolithic design of RME that wasn't possible).

Zooming far out and back in causes a black screen. And a lot of the software just in general, it's like the direction and ideas are nice, but I feel like you need to focus less on adding functionality and make sure what you have added is actually working fully properly, stable, and maintainable. Like right now you have 28 of your own open PR's, that's quite a bit. RME does have quite a few old-school quirks about it, but it's also really quite stable for what it is. Stability is often times more important than new features.

Regardless, this is pretty awesome. I only say my small gripes because I see potential and would like to be able to actually use this.
If it was just a tad less buggy and more stable/organized I would love to jump in more and help you fix things up and submit some PR's, but maybe I will wait a bit to see where this goes because at the moment, it does feel a little all over the place. I respect what you are trying to do with this though, and for releasing it for all to use!

 

[Sorky]

Best thing about vibe coding is... OT community finally has some fricking documentation!
Yeah, it's a big deal. When I was starting again in tibia community guides were either outdated or nonexistent

 

[Glaszcz Koldre]

Webtimize gets all angry at ai generated code, but fails the turing test and likes AI generated coments.
You can't make this shit up, holy shit

 

[sebastian97]

I didn't AI generate my comment lmfao. At all. I wrote that entirely by hand........

...I .... I don't know if I should be flattered or insulted you assumed my response was AI? Is my writing really that sterile?

 

[Webtimize]

Webtimize gets all angry at ai generated code, but fails the turing test and likes AI generated coments.
You can't make this shit up, holy shit

View attachment 98334

I didn't AI generate my comment lmfao. At all. I wrote that entirely by hand........

XDDDDD what the fuck is going on here lol

Edit; you so tilted i offended your empty AI contribution that takes no skill or effort, that you really want to find anything to throw, eh?

 

[sebastian97]

I mean come on, does bro just see dense, structured, well thought-out response and go, YEP, that's AI!
I don't use em-dashes, I don't use any of the common AI tropes, I just type fast and had a lot to say after checking out your project.

 

[Webtimize]

I mean come on, does bro just see dense, structured, well thought-out response and go, YEP, that's AI!
I don't use em-dashes, I don't use any of the common AI tropes, I just type fast and had a lot to say after checking out your project.

Bro thanks to your literacy I failed the turing test :/

How dare I like something coherent and full out written thoughts...

 

[sebastian97]

I do think you could dial it back a bit. Don't get me wrong, I don't like AI slop either.
But, you aren't even being constructive. And let's be honest, people using AI to create open-source Tibia tools are not the enemy.

 

[Webtimize]

I'll die on this hill. It's all slop. Never have I ever seen anything shipped that worked or anything near finished.

All slop

 

[Glaszcz Koldre]

I mean come on, does bro just see dense, structured, well thought-out response and go, YEP, that's AI!
I don't use em-dashes, I don't use any of the common AI tropes, I just type fast and had a lot to say after checking out your project.

You just replied 3 times like a AI bot.

1. I did not say anything about LOD, and you say that "LOD idea was a much needed for the editor". LOD comment is in the binary release, when i say its buggy.
2. AI files are workflows - they are not in the source code. Yet you say its polluted.
3. Scripting its not a part of this repo. Its a part of OTA RME.
4. 28 Pr's are automated tasks

Jesus christ, whole post reads like an AI making post after google research.

 

[Webtimize]

You just replied 3 times like a AI bot.

1. I did not say anything about LOD, and you say that "LOD idea was a much needed for the editor". LOD comment is in the binary release, when i say its buggy.
2. AI files are workflows - they are not in the source code. Yet you say its polluted.
3. Scripting its not a part of this repo. Its from OTA RME.
4. 28 Pr's are automated tasks

Jesus christ, whole post reads like an AI making post after google research.

Bro you are the same shitstain as I am just another color

stfu and check the AI bot's github

new members catching strays over here

 

[sebastian97]

You just replied 3 times like a AI bot.

1. I did not say anything about LOD, and you say that "LOD idea was a much needed for the editor". LOD comment is in the binary release, when i say its buggy.
2. AI files are workflows - they are not in the source code. Yet you say its polluted.
3. Scripting its not a part of this repo. Its a part of OTA RME.
4. 28 Pr's are automated tasks

Jesus christ, whole post reads like an AI making post after google research.

Bruh
1.) If anything that would prove I didn't use LLM, since I myself must have mistaken your optimization that lets you zoom out on the map as an LOD improvement. I was impressed with the performance and being kind to you.
2.)
3.) Ok, yes, then that is a regression hence what I am saying, it's a nice feature from the RME you FORKED that is non-functioning.

It has been REDUCED to this non-functioning menu
4.) Yes, 28 PR's are automated tasks introducing more code, hence my point you are doing too much going forward without going back and maintaining what you created.

I was so respectful in my comment man. I get Webtimize is being a jerk to you, but I offered you constructive criticism from my actual self.

edit:
Ahh I see what you are saying, yes, even though its "part of a workflow" it is still part of your source code, if you clone it down, and it is apart of the files, yes. It is a part of the source code.

 

[Glaszcz Koldre]

3.) Ok, yes, then that is a regression hence what I am saying, it's a nice feature from the RME you FORKED that is non-functioning.

It has been REDUCED to this non-functioning menu

Im sorry, but Scripts are not a part of this repo, since it was forked before Scripts were introduced in OTA Rme.

 

[sebastian97]

Im sorry, but Scripts are not a part of this repo, since it was forked before Scripts were introduced in OTA Rme.

....Yes... but you have a fork... the whole point of a fork is to be able to pull code from the repo you forked from....
Whatever, I'm not trying to grill you. I genuinely thought some of the stuff you did was cool and was just offering some thoughts.

Seems you might be a bit burned out/overwhelmed. Like I said, appreciate the work you've done and sharing it. My feedback stands if you want to revisit it later. Good luck with your project.

 

[Glaszcz Koldre]

....Yes... but you have a fork... the whole point of a fork is to be able to pull code from the repo you forked from....

Im sorry, but this project does not aim for 1:1 RME compatibility. Some features are completely reinvented and may introduce breaking changes. Scripting was introduced 3 weeks ago, and is not compatible with changes I made for the past 2 months.