The Forgotten Server Icon Competition - Voting thread - V3

What submission do you think is the best?


  • Total voters
    258
  • Poll closed .

Worr

Veteran OT User
Joined
Jan 23, 2011
Messages
1,443
Reaction score
356
Location
Sweden
The shadow in icon #1 is interesting and all design elements works for an icon, compared to the other two submissions where details are lost.
 

justikar

Active Member
Joined
Oct 28, 2013
Messages
145
Reaction score
30
the second icon is better than the others.
2 = unique, original and use visual identity from tibia.
1 and 3 = generic, looks like another billions icons from internet

this poll cant be democratic

I fully agree.
 

oen432

Legendary OT User
Joined
Oct 3, 2014
Messages
1,328
Solutions
43
Reaction score
1,433
Location
Poland
GitHub
Oen44
the second icon is better than the others.
2 = unique, original and use visual identity from tibia.
1 and 3 = generic, looks like another billions icons from internet

this poll cant be democratic
You have to understand that this icon must be SCALABLE and out of these 3, #2 is the least. It loses details at lower resolution and looks like a messy blob, before original post was edited, these icons were scaled to 32x32px, which is for example the size of icons on Windows taskbar, and lets be honest, we are taking about an icon, not logo. Most servers are hosted on Linux without graphical interface so icons are not even visible, which means that we are aiming for Windows. So #2 is the worst option, even tho it looks fine at higher resolutions.
 

Shadowsong

Game Developer & Graphic Designer
Joined
Feb 23, 2010
Messages
3,431
Solutions
21
Reaction score
2,897
Location
Bosnia & Herzegovina
#3 seems most elegant and clean while both having the label and the mascot but since it has scalability issues, much like #2 as well, I preferred #1. A modernistic design approach, but a welcome one, I could never take any of that previous stuff seriously.
 

Xikini

I whore myself out for likes
Support Team
Joined
Nov 17, 2010
Messages
5,407
Solutions
360
Reaction score
3,515
Just want to remind everyone, that you can 'Change Vote'.

If the one you liked doesn't look like it's going to win, you can change your vote to your second favourite. :)
 

zbizu

Legendary OT User
Joined
Nov 22, 2010
Messages
3,025
Solutions
18
Reaction score
2,151
Location
Poland
GitHub
Zbizu
The icons can be edited to look better at target resolution btw. ico format allows putting separate images as layers so the layers can be edited to maintain key features, though some programs may have issues recognizing them.
 

Xikini

I whore myself out for likes
Support Team
Joined
Nov 17, 2010
Messages
5,407
Solutions
360
Reaction score
3,515
Only 9 days left. squee
 

Similar threads

Top